Written By Josephine Borghi

Health Economist |  London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine

April 1, 2020

Article originally published by Democracy Without Borders

The coronavirus COVID-19 outbreak has brought into focus the need for a global health system. Infectious disease outbreaks are a global problem that nation states alone cannot tackle. To minimise the damage and effectively contain an outbreak a unified global response is needed.

At present, the lack of effective coordination and oversight at a global level, means that each country’s response is a reflection of its own political and health system, which differs enormously across countries and depends to a large extent on the level of available economic and health care resources. This can result in the implementation of ineffective strategies which are at odds with international cooperation. For example, numerous countries, including the United States, have imposed travel restrictions, temporary border closures and flight bans which do not work in this case.

Pandemic preparedness is a global public good

The key issue is that health systems are currently in the domain of national governments. Yet, as becomes clear when we consider measures to curtail the spread of the COVID-19 outbreak, this means that there is a sovereignty problem because pandemic preparedness represents a global public good and aspects of its response need to happen transnationally. Examples of activities that arguably need to happen at the global level include the development of global guidelines and norms, research and development into vaccines and treatment, outbreak surveillance and early warning systems, and the management of disease transmission across borders. All these activities ideally also need to be funded and managed at the global level. 

In practice, however, it has been reported that these types of activities are underfunded, and although international financing for such activities increased somewhat after the Ebola outbreak, this increase was not sustained. There is an underinvestment in these areas because these are public goods, which suffer from what we call in economics the ‘free rider’ problem: people can benefit without paying. For example, they can benefit from outbreak containment activities carried out by one country, without supporting the cost of that containment . . .

What is World Federalism?

World Federal Government (WFG)

Original Publisher

Democracy Without Borders

Josephine Borghi is a Professor in Health Economics at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine. She is a health economist with 18 years experience. She has expertise in economic evaluation of maternal care interventions and my current research interest is in the evaluation of health financing reforms, including mechanisms to increase health care coverage and financial protection among the informal sector and supply side incentives such as performance based financing.

Related Articles

LIST for DWF NEWS Articles 11/14/24

Genocidal Scorecard  DEATH MARCHES & TORTURE CAMPS Chris Hedges    Scheerpost Israel accused of silencing journalists by killing them The Middle East and the Journalist's Fate Viktor Mikhin     THE INTEL DROP Scandinavians, the World's Happiest People, Love...

LIST of Articles for DWF NEWS 10/31/24

Here's how Israel owns the U.S. Congress How Does AIPAC Shape Washington? We Tracked Every Dollar. Akela Lacy       The Intercept Generating consent for genocide: The BBC's complicity in Israel's crimes in Palestine and Lebanon Sharaiz Chaudhry    Mondoweiss Can the...

LIST of Articles for DWF NEWS 10/17/24

Nazi Germany Used Gas Ovens, Zionist Israel Uses Starvation and Bombing Roger Kotila, PhD      DWF NEWS Extermination Works. At First. Chris Hedges       SheerPost 'Intolerable': Global Outrage as Israeli Forces Fire on UN Peacekeepers in Lebanon Jake...

Solving Global Problems

We can work together to make the world better

Share This